Where the Roof Breaks Open into Sky
Nonie was only ten but she knew things. She sat on the hardwood floor in the front window of the apartment waiting for her mother to come home.
Her sister Emma Lee had climbed into her loft hours ago and sung herself to sleep. Nonie couldn’t sleep when her mother said she was on her way home soon and then she didn’t come.
The streetlight gave her a full view of Carroll St, all the way to Seventh Avenue and if she sat against the bookcase she could see passed St. Joseph’s Church where her mother would turn toward home, unless she took a cab which she sometimes did, especially at this time of night or when she was later than she said she would be.
The glow of the light shone even on Nonie’s face and reflected back her image on the clean window. She had used Windex on it herself so she knew it was clean but the dirt from the Brooklyn street left a grey film on the outside and Nonie wondered how people ever got their windows really clean unless they sat out on their fire escapes and theirs was on the back of their building. Maybe that’s why her mother liked to sit so long at the kitchen table on Saturdays, her head resting on her chin, her eyes wide open looking at something that Nonie couldn’t see. She sat there with her coffee and notebook until the end of Saturday morning cartoons and Nonie and Emma Lee were hungry for lunch and wanting to play in the park.
Nonie could see her own eyes looking back at her in the window, like her mother’s but different, sadder and less quick. She looked out into them as if she had a question but didn’t know what it was, but had the answer instead.
She had to sit here, to be there waiting when her mother got home. It was all she could do, this waiting, this looking.
Old man Murray had been sitting on the stoop across the way smoking but he’d gone to bed. Bernard Willis had come home from the ballroom dancing school on the corner. She’d already seen him glide up the street in his shiny tuxedo, the silly red handkerchief he puffed out of his pocket, all droopy and used. All the lights on the street were off except for the green emerald shade above her on the bookcase, even Mary Margaret Mayfield’s mother had come in from the night shift and pulled the chain in the hallway.
Nonie had been downstairs to turn it back on and check the mail. Her mother would forget both or leave the little key in the box. She would be happy when she finally came through the door but wobbly in her high heeled shoes…
A car door slammed shut. She hadn’t seen the cab come slowly up the street looking for their address. Nonie had been looking hard at herself in the mirror. Down below she saw her mother’s cherry red beret, her head turned up at the window.
Nonie jumped back from the window, sat in the dark, waiting for the fumbling at the lock, the click of her heels…
* * *
It wasn’t any good inside and it wasn’t any good outside. Nonie couldn’t be Nonie, not anymore. She had to be Nan Marie. She had to take her name back from her mother.
Nonie became Nonie when she was only two. She didn’t like to go to bed before the sun so she’d say “No”. She didn’t like to take a bath with her sister so she’d say “No”. She didn’t like fish sticks, especially the way her mother overcooked them until they looked liked black chewing gum and tasted like crunchy dirt. She’d spit them out on her plate and say, “No”. No became her favorite word and so her mother called her Nonie.
Nonie wanted her name back, Nan Marie, after her grandmother, the queen of France, and even the virgin mother, or that’s what her sister had said one day when she liked her, probably her birthday, since that only happened maybe once each year.
And now her sister had left her alone and taken her uppity self off to college. And now her mother Bette, short for Elizabeth but spelled like Bette Davis, came home even later after work. She said she hated her job on Wall Street but she stayed there late almost every night.
Nan Marie didn’t sit by the window anymore and wait for her, no, not anymore, and she didn’t scrape the black crust off the bottom of the frying pan either, after the fire started on their stove and the smoke alarm went off and woke up the whole building. She didn’t care what her mother did, not anymore. She didn’t care if she ever came home again of if her sister did either. From now on, Nan Marie would take care of herself.
She looked down at the book in her lap, turned the polished cover over and brought the picture of the sad, black woman closer to her face. Nan Marie knew her caged bird but she also saw the woman’s big beauty and heard her ferocious heart beat behind her deep eyes, heavy with something, but she sang still, even after everything she’d seen, everything she’d been through. With every word she still sang, threw her head back, her sad eyes closed, letting out the truth with her voice.
The creak of the old wooden rocker back and forth, back and forth, told time or did it keep her still so it didn’t matter what time it was. She looked out the brownstone window and then pulled the shade down hard, no more streetlights, no more waiting.
Nonie, Nan Marie, put the book face down on the desk, stood up, and began pacing, the new soles of her shoes tapping the polished wood floor, the sound like the creak of the rocker keeping time, marking it. The clock in the hall ticking, the sound in her chest hard.
Today she would tell her, tell her mother that she wanted her name back, the name she’d been given when she was born. She didn’t want any more allowance. She didn’t even want her bed. She would be leaving. Noni, Nan Marie, had saved enough bus fare to see Chicago for herself, to find her father, and tell him what had been going on in New York City.
The phone rang in the kitchen—one, two, three times. Only one person would call this late and she wasn’t about to answer. Soon she heard the syrupy drawl of her mother’s voice, “Noonie, Noonie, darlin’, I’ll see you in the morning, OK, sweetheart? Lock the doors now.”
The echo behind her sounded like street noise, but she didn’t care. She knew where she wasn’t.
Nonie pulled up the shade until it snapped into a roll popping the top of the window frame; the streetlight flickered like an old movie. Soft rain fell washing away the pigeon poop from the outside sill.
Nonie picked the book back up from the desk, continued her rocking, sang herself to sleep.
* * *
Bette heard her daughter’s voice, big, self-assured, heavy with need, speaking into the answering machine, unwelcoming her as she pulled the big, iron gate open with one flexed foot, the bag of groceries tipping dangerously forward, her backpack grinding into her shoulders, somehow still able to hold the keys in her hand, to turn the bolt, then push open the inside door with her bad knee. The heavy wrought iron slammed into her backpack and Bette fell to her knees, grapefruit rolling ahead of her through the entranceway caught by a dust-ball under the coat-rack.
She caught the eggs but sacrificed her elbow and looking down saw the gash in the apple-green cashmere sweater she’d worn only once.
Tears flew from her eyes from an overfull fountain as if she’d fallen from a childhood game of pile-on. “Mom,” she heard Nonie’s voice again, “Please, pick up, jeez, Mom, where are you?” still louder and more insistent, as the machine cut her off with its long shrill beep.
Bette let go and lay flat on her belly on the cold floor until her tears stopped coming, heaving like a child. Her ribs hurt, and she wondered if she’d broken something, broken something in her chest, her breastplate, the armor across her sternum pierced and shattered, no longer able to protect the mush inside her, to prevent it from oozing forth, so deep, so red…
She wished that she could just stay prone, feel the cool wood under her cheek, the scent of cedar wafting from the coat closet and a faint hint of peppermint. When she realized the mint was artificial and coming from the too-full cat box in the adjacent laundry room she picked up the eggs beside her and wobbled to her feet, stripes of riddled thread running down her black tights, holes at the knee. The eggs, organic, she smiled, fresh from Murray’s Farm, worth every penny of the $3.50 she’d paid for them. She placed them on the three-legged table next to the coat rack and finally set the key into the lock.
Inside the dark paneled front room reminiscent of a ship captain’s quarters, she fumbled for the lamp near the door and turned it on, its light fanning across her unmade bed, the lilac comforter bunched and fluffed as if someone lay beneath it. Her computer screen flickered at her desk where she’d forgotten to sleep it. The old cat Zoë met her in the hall with a loud meow nearly tripping her again as she rubbed up against her legs.
Bette plopped in the overstuffed chair by the phone, her coat stained with something sticky—peanut butter—her hand bruised, her neck aching, her tights stuck to her knees where the fall had scraped away her skin.
She put her head back and eased down into the worn floral chintz and if the doorbell had not buzzed at that moment she would have forgotten the groceries strewn across the hall like lost memories.
“Hello, hello, Miss Mason, are you there?”
“Oh, no,” she said out loud, jumping too quick to her feet: Isaac, her student, his English test tomorrow, she’d promised to help him—all this coming to her at once.
“Miss Mason,” she heard him call again through the gate, “I see you.”
“Coming, coming,” she called back to him, and as she moved toward the front door to the brownstone, the sight of him healed her, the blue of his eyes, his bright, worried gaze, the nose too big for his small pink face.
“Miss Mason, you’re crying, and your sweater, it’s torn, has someone hurt you?”
“Don’t worry,” her eyes said and together they kneeled and gathered the spilled food back into its bag, the little boy half her size helping her again to her feet.
* * *
After Isaac’s lesson, Bette returned to her chintz chair in the kitchen, where she awoke to the old cat’s rub against her ankles, the house dark, the clock on the VCR blinking 1:31. She undressed as she walked down the hall to her unmade bed and crawled into it. Through the wall, she heard the neighbor’s television blaring, a man shouting loudly. As she tried to sleep, the echo of her grandfather’s voice took her to a Sunday dinner long ago after church. She wore a yellow dotted Swiss dress and only a cotton slip, no bra, she must have been 10 or 11, her brother barely four sat in a booster seat diagonally across from her next to their mother, her father on her left, Papa, her grandfather, at the head of the table, Nana at the other end, all in their usual places.
Fresh fruit set in brightly colored Fiestaware bowls set before each of them—cantaloupe, watermelon, strawberries, grapes—smothered in French dressing. As he sat down, her father made an idle comment about the strange choice of dressing and Papa snatched her father’s bowl from in front of him and dumped its fruit on tope of his own portion, saying: “Too good for your hoity, toity tastes? Who do you think you are criticizing the meal laid before you?”
“Sir, I’m sorry. I just…”
“Shut your mouth, you’re lucky to have such a meal. And your job, if it weren’t for me….let’s see, do you still eat roast beef?” and with this flung a slab of overcooked meat on his son’s plate, the juice splattering on to his crisp white shirt.
Everyone at the table jumped and too the meat that the old man delivered to each of their plates but with less intention.
“I’m sorry, sir, I didn’t…”
“Didn’t you hear me? I said shut your mouth!”
“Please, Daddy,” his wife spoke up trying to quiet him.
“You, too, shut up. When was the last time you cooked a meal?”
And so the Sunday dinner unfolded, the little boy blinking back and forth between his giant grandfather, his father, who looked down at his plate like a wounded animal not yet felled; his mother, anxious, fidgeting with the little boy’s meat, cutting it into tinier and tinier pieces; the girl, seeing tears well up in her father’s eyes, wanting to touch his leg, but not knowing what he would do.
Silence among them for some time, only the sound of smacking lips, swallowing, without breathing, deep sighs.
Nana finally said, “Daddy, it’s so good, the beef, well done, just the way I like it.”
The father chewed and chewed and chewed. He liked his meat juicy with plenty of pink, the girl remembered this as she listened and watched, his face the color of the radish on his plate, swimming alone beside the collards, okra, tomatoes, and over boiled potatoes.
Elizabeth knew what was to come and sure enough soon after the coconut cake too sweet for their upset bellies they were in the car, the key in the ignition, engine racing, her mother’s legs crossed looking out her side mirror as he backed out, forgetting to check the sidewalk behind them.
“Careful, watch out,” was all she said as the boy on the bicycle came into his view and he stepped hard on the break lurching the children forward and the beautiful, careful wife into her visor.
“Goodness,” she said, as the back of his hand with the large red stone of his college ring hit the side of her face, knob on bone. She cried out and he said, “Shut your mouth,” and she did and they didn’t say another word or make a sound as the car pulled onto the suburban road and flipped on the radio to hear the ball scores.
The girl, then glad she had not soothed him, hated him, wanted him to die, and she flew away on the next bird’s wing, high above the car into the blue space. When she looked down again, the tiny red car moved slowly along the grey ribbon of road, the feathers soft beneath her skirt, the kind and gentle bird taking her where she needed to go, without a word.
Her eye still on the car she watched it turn and pull into its box as they swooped closer settling onto the winding oak that hung over the road in front of her house. She could hear them now and she would peck his eyes out if she could, and her friend turned to her and spoke, saying, “No, this is not a thought you want to have,” and she released the intensity of her gaze, the scowl on her face easing. She knew she must return to the hard ground, her little brother was alone except for the tired, worn brown monkey that swung limply from his hand. The other hung tight to their mother’s hand, she thought, or was she holding on to her son like he held on to his monkey?
The bird nudged her with his yellow beak and she flew on her own floating to a soft land, the heels of her red Mary Jane’s catching the ground. She stood for a moment to be there again and walked into the garage, the slam of the doors and the tone of his voice bellowing as her steps hit the brick of the breezeway and she stood with them all again at the back door, her father impatient with the lock, loud like Papa, his face still as red as the radish on his lunch plate. Her mother stood as still as she could like a wilted flower in her fuchsia silk wet stains under both arms.
Elizabeth placed both hands on her little brother’s golden head like she saw Father Benton do for those who were not yet ready for Holy Communion. He looked up at her with his nut-brown eyes and she saw what he saw in her freckled face. She smiled with her eyes much like his. Their mother could not see them as she looked down at her shoes. Bette wished she could take them both into the wide blue space but she knew they must find their own way.
On an ordinary day, her mother might ask her father not to grumble so loudly about the stiff lock but today she said nothing as he fumbled and cursed. She watched as her mother’s ears folded into themselves like day lilies at the end of their day.
Once inside the kitchen, her father pushed the breakfast room chair out of his way and Shadow, their big black cat with the white beard, ran between his legs nearly tripping him. She wished he had and the bird’s face came to her reminding her that thoughts like these would make her like them, Papa and her father, and this would be the last thing she would want, to be mean and hurt people who she loved and wanted to love her.
“Have you cleaned your room, Elizabeth?” her father barked at her as he threw his jacket over the chair in front of the fireplace they never used and moved toward the stairs.
“Not yet,” she answered quietly, as he ordered her up to her room, the crystal beads shaking on the chandelier in the entrance hall as his voice boomed and his heavy steps pounded the stairs.
Her mother fluttered behind him saying something to her brother about putting on some play clothes as she slowed her pace behind her husband still holding on to her son’s hand.
Elizabeth watched from the bottom of the staircase, looking up at the ceiling where patterns of color—lavender, rose, and pale green quivered in the mid-afternoon sun coming in through the transom over the front door.
“What are you waiting for?” he called after her over the banister above, as she imagined him falling, cracking his head open on the hard brick, landing at her feet.
She looked from his red face to the light patterns now moving down the wall and she saw the bird’s eyes in their flickering and remembered who she was and did not want to be.
Watching her red Mary Janes scamper up the stairs after her mother and brother, she followed into the children’s part of the house, as her father turned to look at them before slamming the door to her study behind him.
Elizabeth imagined the roof turning to clouds and opening into the blue space, the sound of waves from the nearby Gulf, where white sand reached far, both left and right, and everyone was swimming. Her mother sat on the beach in her black and white bathing suit talking to her sister who wore the same suit in red. Her brother, still a baby, played in the portable playpen and the men, her father and her uncle showed off their big fish. She and her cousins waved from the sandbar, miles away, where the turquoise water was only up to their knees and they caught crabs for supper with their bare hands.
“Elizabeth, hang up your dress and get started on your room before there is a fuss.”
She heard her mother but through a mist from far out in the low-tide waves.
“Elizabeth, focus, you must get to your room. I’ve made your bed but these things on the floor must be put away. I’ve told you about taking out watercolors on the rug—only on the back porch on newspaper.”
“Yes, Mother, I know, but I wanted to make a card for you of the waves like at the beach. Will we go this summer?”
“Yes, I don’t know, dear, let’s get our church clothes off. Now hurry along. You help your brother, won’t you?”
And she was gone through the door, the latch clicking into place behind her, only a scent of lemon, gardenias, she called it. Was that a flower? she wondered. What could such a flower look like? Round and full like a skirt of white ruffles?
And she heard him again through the wall. “I told you,” he screamed. “I told you to shut your mouth,” and she knew it was not the door slamming but her mother. No, not that…and she wanted to lift off back into the blue space, the clouds above, but she heard her brother, the snuffling whimper coming from under his door, his whisper, calling her name…and her heels came back to the ground and she went to him, flipping on the radio beside his bed as a woman’s sweet voice sang, “you can always go, downtown, downtown”.
Her brother sat on the round braided rug between his twin beds as if afloat on a raft, his old brown monkey beside him, his eyes wide and tears frozen upon his cheeks.
“Don’t worry,” she said, “I’ll read you a story. How about Big Bear?”
He nodded. She closed the door and sat down beside him on the raft reaching out over the water for the book beside his bed, Little Bear Goes To School.
“Not that one,” he said pointing to the high shelf.
“OK,” she said standing, her arms out to her sides like wings, as if for balance or to fly over the water to reach it if she must. “Little Bear Has a Birthday”? she asked.
“Yes,” he said, the tears melting now and drying up, his eyes like stars.
Far away on shore she heard a loud voice and something hitting the wall. She turned up the radio before lifting herself back onto the raft, the woman still singing, “when you are lonely…” and she settled down with her brother, not lonely at all, as their knees touched and the old brown monkey sat up to listen, as she began, “It was Little Bear’s Birthday and his mother would bake him a cake.”
She took her brother’s hand as they rode the gentle waves. “Little Bear wanted chocolate cake with white icing and it would have six candles.”
Her brother’s eyes widened and he said, “I will be six after I am five, right?”
“Yes.”
“After nursery school I will go to big boy kindergarten, right?”
“Right.” And the waves rolled gently beneath them as the loud voice stopped but the wall shook like thunder inn the distance.
“Little Bear knew this meant he would soon go to school.”
“And I am my mama’s little bear, right?” her brother asked.
“Yes,” and the stars fell from his eyes, “Daddy won’t hurt Mommy, right? And you will stay with me here, right?”
“I will stay with you forever,” she said and picked up his stars and put them in the great blue space so he could be where he was on the raft and not be afraid.
And without warning someone broke down the door and called her name from not so far away but her brother couldn’t fly and she told him she would be right back and while she was gone he needed to take care of Monk and she turned up the radio and gave him a pillow for a cloud and waved to him from across the water and he held it close, as he lay on the raft holding tight to his monkey’s hand.
Elizabeth closed the door and tiptoed toward her room and began to tidy it, the watercolors dry, her brushes neatly in their cup of water now blue violet.
He came into the room without knocking and yanked her up under her arm where it was wet like her mother’s and shouted, “I told you to clean up this mess! What have you been doing?”
“Reading to Harry,” she said looking down at her shoes.
“I told you to clean up this mess, look at it, you know you are not to paint in your room!”
And still holding her hard by the arm, he kicked the paints and stepped on the clean, white paper where she’d made a sun shine and his giant footprint stayed there making a shadow.
“And these drawers, can’t you close them?”
And he yanked her desk drawer open finding a Sweet Tart wrapper. Throwing her into the desk chair he pulled it out and all of the tiny candies fell onto the floor and he stomped on them and told her to sweep them up with her hands, as he pulled out another drawer upending its contents onto the floor. Her pink diary fell open and hit her chin and he grabbed it from her as they both reached for it.
“And what might you write in here?”
She said, “Give me that!”
And he stood back as if to get his balance, the whites of his eyes green, and he slapped her straight away, the crack of his hand stinging through her skin to the bone, her ears ringing.
“Wipe that sneer off your stupid face!”
But she couldn’t and froze as he unbuckled his belt and pulled it from his pants like a lasso, the tail of it on fire. He told her to stand and she did but would not look at him again in the eye and she turned looking through the blue flowers on her wall until she saw the raft, reached her hand out to Harry, as her father hurled the first swipe at her backside, and again, this one harder, as she hit the wall—like her mother. And she flew to the raft and they lifted off. Her room with the blue flowers fell below her and the man with the belt who had been her father grew smaller and smaller and smaller until he was out of sight, only the wide open blue, and the bird, his feathers beneath them, taking them where they must go.